What happened
On 5 November the Guardian reported that the British College of Aesthetic Medicine had extended its “vet it before you get it” campaign to surgery abroad, with a checklist telling patients to confirm a surgeon’s qualifications, find out what emergency facilities are near the clinic and ask what insurance the practitioner holds. A former president of the British Association of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons said the risk of surgery abroad starts when you board the plane and ends when you are out of the clotting window, and that a lack of in-person aftercare was her main concern. A medical negligence lawyer said Türkiye is the most popular destination for British patients and the hardest in which to bring a claim.
I treat British patients every week, so I read the list as a set of questions addressed to me. Here are my answers, item by item, including the two that do not flatter the country I work in.
The common misconception
The misconception on the British side is that a checklist is a warning: that the questions exist to talk you out of going. The misconception on the Turkish side is that the questions are an insult. Neither is right. A checklist is a filter, and a good surgeon abroad should want the filter to be strict, because it removes the clinics that make the whole country look like them. Every question on the British list is one I can answer in a sentence, with evidence. That is what the list is for.
The clinical reality
Qualifications and registration: three documents, each checkable. The list asks whether the practitioner is medically qualified and registered and can give a registration number. In Türkiye the Ministry of Health keeps every doctor’s diploma and specialty registration in a database that is not public, so the equivalent of a register entry is the registration document I generate from the e-Devlet government portal, which carries a QR code and a barcode anyone can verify on the portal’s document verification page. Beyond that, the specialty is confirmed by two societies that admit only plastic surgeons: my ISAPS profile and the member list of the Turkish Society of Plastic Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgeons. Ask for all three before you ask the price; they take a minute each.
Who actually operates, and who gives the anesthetic. The list asks who supervises clinical work. In my practice the answer has no layers: I operate, in a hospital, with an anesthesiologist who is in the room for the whole case and stays for the monitored first night. There is no junior surgeon finishing the case, no nurse giving sedation between patients. I have written separately about why the room matters as much as the surgeon; the short version is that this question deserves a specific answer: a name, a specialty and a room.
Insurance: it exists, it is compulsory, and it is the surgeon’s professional cover. Since 30 July 2010 every physician practicing in Türkiye has been required by law to hold medical malpractice liability insurance covering material and moral damages and legal costs for claims arising from professional activity. I carry it, as every licensed surgeon here must. I want to be precise about what it is, because patients misunderstand it: it is professional liability cover that insures the physician against claims, not a policy in the patient’s name. It does not make a bad outcome less likely, and it does not pay for a result you dislike. It pays a claim in which negligence is established. That is exactly why the British list tells you to ask about it, and exactly why the answer in Türkiye is a legal fact rather than a clinic’s promise.
Experience: ask the number, I give the number. The British government’s own travel advice tells patients to ask for examples of a practitioner’s experience with the specific operation. I do not find the question impertinent. If you ask how many of a given operation I have done, I tell you, and I tell you how many I do in a typical year, because the answer belongs to you. What I will not do is publish a league table on a website, where it becomes marketing rather than information.
Emergency facilities: in the building, not near it. The list asks what emergency facilities are near the clinic. The right answer is not “near”. The hospital I operate in has an intensive care unit in the same building and an anesthesiologist on site through the night; blood is not stored on the premises and is requested from the national blood system when needed. For a combined body operation or any long case, I will not operate anywhere that cannot say the same, and I have set out where I draw that line.
Governance: the facility is licensed for you specifically. A hospital or clinic that treats international patients in Türkiye must hold the Ministry of Health’s International Health Tourism Authorization, and the Ministry publishes the lists; I explained how to read them in my article on what the ISAPS data say about Türkiye, where the more useful number also sits: 70.6 percent of aesthetic operations here are done in hospitals, against 37.9 percent in the United States and 32.1 in Germany.
Aftercare and the clotting window: the two points where the critics are right. The former BAAPS president is correct that the risk runs from the flight out to the end of the clotting window, and that distance makes aftercare harder. My answer is not to argue but to show the plan: the first night in hospital, drains out when output allows, walking the same day in compression stockings, a fly-home date fixed by the operation rather than the ticket, a written medical report in English for your doctor at home, and a WhatsApp line the surgical team answers the same day for as long as you are healing. The recovery planner shows the timeline procedure by procedure. The British travel advice says a patient under general anesthesia should plan to stay in the country at least ten days. My own protocol is five to seven days for most operations and seven for large combined procedures, and the fly-home date is set before you travel, according to the operation.
Legal recourse: harder across a border, and not absent. The lawyer quoted by the Guardian is right that a claim from Britain against a Turkish surgeon is harder than a claim against one in Leeds. It is not impossible: Turkish law gives patients the right to complain and to sue, the compulsory insurance exists to pay established claims, and a hospital case has records a clinic case may not. What I can add is the thing the British campaign now calls an aesthetic passport: keep your consent form, your operation note, your implant card if you had one, your discharge report and the name of the hospital. I give all of them. A patient who has them has a case file; a patient who has a brochure has a brochure.
The practical takeaway for patients
Send the checklist. The campaign’s point is that you can ask the awkward questions before any money moves, and you are entitled to the answers.
Expect documents, not reassurance. For each item above there is a piece of paper or a page: a verifiable registration document, two society listings, a hospital name you can look up on the Ministry’s list, a written aftercare timeline, a report in English at discharge.
Ask the two uncomfortable questions anyway: how many of these have you done, and what happens if I need to make a claim. The answers should be a number and a plain explanation.
Treat the holiday as the problem, not the bonus. Surgery is the reason for the trip; the sea is where you will not be swimming for several weeks.
Honest limits
I have answered the list for my own practice, not for Türkiye, and the Guardian’s experts are describing the clinics I would also tell you to avoid. The compulsory insurance has limits per claim and a process that takes time; it is a safety net, not a guarantee of compensation. Aftercare at a distance is genuinely harder than aftercare across town, and no messaging line replaces a surgeon’s hands on the wound; what it replaces is silence. And the checklist itself was written for British clinics first; I have mapped its questions to the Turkish system as faithfully as I can, and where the systems differ I have said so.
If you want the documents behind these answers before you decide anything, write to +90 544 772 0772; the surgical team sends them the same day, no photographs required.
Dr. Mustafa Aydınol is a plastic, reconstructive and aesthetic surgeon in Istanbul and a member of ISAPS.
Sources
- The Guardian, 5 November 2026: beware “sun, sea and surgery” cosmetic tourism packages, experts advise. Link
- British College of Aesthetic Medicine. Vet It Before You Get It: pre-consultation safety questionnaire covering credentials, supervision, insurance, products, emergency protocols and clinic governance. Link
- UK Government, Travel Aware: surgery abroad, cut out the risk; checklist including practitioner verification through official host-country sources, asking about experience, a medical report in English, and a stay of at least ten days after general anesthesia. Link
- Republic of Türkiye, Official Gazette, 21 July 2010, no. 27648: compulsory medical malpractice liability insurance for physicians under Law 1219, Additional Article 12, in force 30 July 2010. Link
- Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Health, Health Tourism Department: health facilities holding the International Health Tourism Authorization. Link
- International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery. ISAPS International Survey on Aesthetic/Cosmetic Procedures Performed in 2025: practice-setting tables by country. Link







